Reviews for Phantom
| LilBuffy |
05/06/06 - 05:54AM |
1: Prologue |
Signed |
| Oh My God! WOW! I love the movie The Phantom of the Opera and this strory amazes me trlu its the best fanfic i've ever read on The Slayer Archive really, i really love this story , and the music's enchantingxxxemmaxxx |
| Monkey Pants |
01/20/06 - 07:23PM |
6: Chapter Five |
Signed |
| Emotional chapter, and the music insertion helped muchly. |
| Monkey Pants |
12/16/05 - 09:56AM |
5: Chapter Four |
Signed |
| I like the Willow/Alexander substory, I think it compliments the main plot well. Riley is obviously going to be the opposite of the romantic hero...then again, he was never romantic in the show anyway... |
| Monkey Pants |
12/06/05 - 07:52AM |
3: Chapter Two |
Signed |
Another great chapter. Its funny, because the real Angel would never think of himself as an Angel of Music :P You've done a good job with the crossover well done
Author's Response: As always, thank you for the great comments. I'm so glad you think I handled the crossover well because well, Phantom and Buffy isn't exactly a conventional crossover :) Again, thank you!! |
| Monkey Pants |
12/01/05 - 03:48AM |
4: Chapter Three |
Signed |
Riley is nicely hateable in this story, which sets up Angel well :) The story's getting creepier now... great chapter
Author's Response: Again, thank you so much - I really appreciate it :) And to succeed at making Angel the hero, we've gotta make the vicomte nasty. Glad to know it worked :) Thank you again!! |
| Monkey Pants |
12/01/05 - 03:46AM |
2: Chapter One |
Signed |
Another great chapter. i like the fact that you've kept the original lyrics :)
Author's Response: Thank you so much - glad you liked. Yeah, I had to use some of the songs. I've been listening to the soundtrack for years, I've just recently seen the movie (like 15 times now) and I'm going to see the show in January. So yeah, love the music :) |
| Peaches Girl |
11/28/05 - 08:27AM |
28: Dedication |
Signed |
Awe. Your awsome. I loved every word of this fic. I have read your story and I think its great. You are a great writer and I think you will go far. I hope to aspire to do as good as you but alas I am but a mere fic lover and writer. All the others are so much better, but thanks for the shout out. Hope you do update the other story I cant wait to read it. Thanks again.
Author's Response: Thank you so very much for everything - I seriously can't begin to thank you enough for all the phenomenal support from beginning to end, as well as your dedicated support on my other stories. And I don't know what you're talking about - your writing kicks butt!! I love your stories, truly I do. They're so much fun to read, and I've enjoyed all of them thus far. As always, thank you, thank you, thank you times a million!!! |
| i_hate_mornings |
11/28/05 - 06:18AM |
27: Chapter Twenty-Six |
Signed |
Great! Absolutely fantstic. The ending was unreal. I loved this peice. I love your work. It's truly great reading
Author's Response: As always, I seriously can't thank you enough for all the kind reviews. It really means so very much to me, and I'm so glad you enjoyed the story and the ending. Thank you a million times over for everything!! |
| spudicus87 |
11/28/05 - 05:57AM |
1: Prologue |
Signed |
I loved this fic. Great job all around. Can't wait for your next fic.
Author's Response: Thank you so much!! I'm so happy you enjoyed it, and I really appreciate the kind words!! |
| always angel |
11/28/05 - 03:23AM |
28: Dedication |
Signed |
Thank you for the dedication,you're too kind:) Don't worry about lying about Into The Night, I for one don't mind. Its an awesome story and I think you should try to have it published. I'm sad that Phantom is over but can't wait to read more of The Island and your other stories. oh, when you go see Phantom of the opera you have to tell me (in detail!) how it was! Lol.
Author's Response: Glad to know you're cool with it. I mean I know it isn' t like I committed a cardinal sin or something, but I just felt kinda bad about it. I hope to get it published, especially because I've got a whole series thing planned out. But, darn it, I've got to finish the thing first, which seems to be my biggest problem. And your welcome for the dedication - believe me, its well deserved - your stuff is awesome!!! Oh, don't worry, I'll give details - I'm so excited for it :) Thanks again for everything!! |
| always angel |
11/28/05 - 03:14AM |
27: Chapter Twenty-Six |
Signed |
For a second there I thought Angel had died. Fantastic ending and beautifully written, it couldn't be any better. I like how you added in the play . Again great job. I love this story!
Author's Response: I worried that having Angel write "Phantom of the Opera" would be a little corny, but it seemed right. Glad you liked it :) I'm also happy to hear I tricked you for a minute there - as evil as that sounds, but that was what I was going for :) As always, thank you a million times over. Your support is appreciated more than words can say. Again, THANK YOU!!!! |
| Sinister |
11/28/05 - 01:34AM |
28: Dedication |
Signed |
Thank you so much for the dedication but...like I said before...its not you who should be thanking us but us who should be thanking you for giving us such a wonderful story to read. Thank you from the bottom of my heart this was truely amazing work. As for the Into the Night thing...I have to admit it's the only one of your fics I haven't read yet. Not for any particular reason but just for lack of the time to read it. I think that was a smart idea though to change the names of your orginal work. It must have taken a lot to tell us that you did that and to put it out there that is a completely orginal idea. In fact now that I know this I actually can't wait to read it even more then before. I too have a confession to make.....I'm not a big reader. I've very picky. I look at something and if I think I'm not going to like it I don't even bother reading it. I don't have a favorite book or a favorite story or anything like that because nothing really sticks out for me I'm just a picky little bitch lol. But your work is amazing. It actually keeps ME...little miss ants in my pants picky nikki (as my friends call me) I think your stuff is awesome and it keeps me completely interested. I have 100% faith in you that you can get your stuff published some day and when you do you better send me an email, a review on one of my stories or something to let me know what it is and where I can get a copy. I also promise that as soon as I get enough time I am DEFINITLY going to read Into the Night and I'll be critical and tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth about it. I'm not all that great with gramatical errors as you can probably tell but I'll look for those too. Again...I know I've been going on for a long time now but I just have to say that your a great auther and I think your def gonna make it in the writing world. Keep up the amazing work and (as I've said hundreds of times before) never stop writing!
Author's Response: Picky Nikki - lol - that's cute. But hey, seriously, that's a huge compliment for me because if I can interest somone who isn't a big reader, then I really know I'm doing my job, and that just brings a huge smile to my face because, well reading and writing are a large part of my life. Seriously, I started wanting to learn how to read when I was 2, and I haven't stopped since. As for the writing, that started at 6, and well, definitely hasn't stopped since!! Considering I'm 23, that's a long time :) And I hope your faith in me is well deserved - I hope I can be published ... well, as soon as I finish the darn book. Hey, I'll be the first to send you an autographed copy so if I get as famous as Stephen King or something, you can sell it on Ebay for lots of money - lol!!! Yeah, well I doubt that'll happen, but its nice to dream :) And I'm so happy to hear you'll read Into the Night - but please, I'm begging you to be brutally honest. If you don't like it, that's totally cool. Everyone isn't going to like everything I write, and I'm seriously okay with that. Obviously, I'll warn you, some things in this version on the site vary slightly from the original version (aside from the names, obviously). But, more or less, its the same story I'm hoping to get to a publisher at some point and time. As always, I thank you for everything. Your support is deeply appreciated, and look at me ranting now :) Can you tell I love to talk ... er, rather write?? Again, I seriously can't thank you enough!!! |
| Sinister |
11/28/05 - 01:16AM |
27: Chapter Twenty-Six |
Signed |
**claps loudly** AMAZING!!!! It was perfect ending to a perfect story. I just wish I could shake the hand of the auther that wrote such a wonderful masterpeice. I mean every word I say. I never give praise when it isn't due but it is definitly due here. Wonderful job and you definitly EXCEDDED my espectations. I expected greatness of course and then you give me this...again...AMAZING! Seriously wonderful job! **gives another round of applause**
Author's Response: Masterpiece ... hmm ... I think I could get used to that :) I'm so happy I was able to make this story happen, and I'm thrilled that so many people enjoyed it. Again, I can't tell you how much your kind words mean to me. They are deeply, deeply appreciated. Seriously, you're one of the best - you always put a HUGE smile on my face :) |
| Sinister |
11/28/05 - 01:00AM |
26: Chapter Twenty-Five |
Signed |
Again I say....WOW!!!! Amazing chapter and I agree...lots of stuff I didn't see coming. I knew Riley was going to get what was coming to him but I def didn't think it would be Cordy. I kind of saw the whole Xander helping at the last minute thing but that was perfect...didn't see him getting shot though...very scary! It's also so weird to see Buffy not being able to help and defend herself. I just keep thinking shes going to snap out of it and get that slayer strangth going again lol. Anway I just hope Angel is ok. I love happy enddings. I love love love happy enddings...no matter how unrealistic they are. Anyway as usual AMAZING chapter! I was on the edge of my seat...literaly. You shouldn't be thanking us for reviewing...we should be thanking you for writing. Great job and Thank you for writing such an amazing fic for all of us to read.
Author's Response: Isn't it strange though - to put Buffy in a role where she's powerless? When I was writing, I kept thinking the same thing - I just wish she could turn around and throw Riley through a wall ... but then, that wouldn't be totally realistic for this fic :) And really, you are such a sweetheart - for you to think so highly of my writing ... honestly, I cannot tell you how much that means to me! Thank you so much for all the super kind words - I'm just so happy I was able to create something that so many people enjoyed. |
| Sinister |
11/28/05 - 12:29AM |
25: Chapter Twenty-Four |
Signed |
WOW! I don't really know what else to day besides...WOW! This was an amazing chapter. Extreamly powerful. I can't believe Jenny's really dead though. I loved her character. I do understand though how some deaths are nessesary otherwise its just too easy. Anyway amazing job as usual. Just....like I said before....WOW!
Author's Response: It was a tough decision, but something I felt had to be done. But at least we know if Jenny had the choice, she'd do the same thing again because Angel was her dearest friend ... so well, even though she died, I'd have to say she didn't have any regrets. Thanks again for the fantastic reviews!! |
[Previous] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 [Next]
|
|
|
|
Rave
Barbie Girl (Becca)
biscuit07
Filmtheory (Jim)
Malice (Jess)
MebbtheScribe (MichaelB)
Reset (Allie)
Shay (Marrisa)
somnambulist29 (Shea)
Stephanie Loss
Wendyness (Wendy)
Questions?Contact Us
|
|
All stories on this site have been archived with the authors' consent. Do not copy these stories for your own uses without the express consent of the author themselves. Buffy the Vampire Slayer TM and Angel TM are © UPN, WB, Fox and its related entities. All photos on the site are © UPN, Fox, Warner Bros, and/or their respective owners. No profits are being made by use of these images.
Powered with the assitance of eFiction.
|
|
|
